About this podcast
Jay and Jeff take on the best and worst the holiday horror world has to offer. Watch as two semi-qualified critics slog through endless shlock to finally answer the question, what is the pie for? WARNING: Strong language is used so don’t listen around little ones.
Visit Horror for the Holidays page
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 75: Krampus
by e_xander on December 22, 2025Send us a text Jeff and Jay find out what happens when you lose the Christmas spirit and get attacked by killer Gingerbread men! Krampus is there too! Kind of! […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 44: Exploring Creepypasta Vol. 2!by e_xander on December 15, 2025
Send us a text Jeff and Jay join Squidward on the sewer slide! Listen to this episode of the Horror for the Holidays podcast Author: Horror For The Holidays […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 74: ATMby e_xander on December 8, 2025
Send us a text Jeff and Jay battle their way through the field of plot holes and wasted opportunities to withdraw some cash! Was it worth it? You decide! Also […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 43: Thanksgiving Draftby e_xander on December 1, 2025
Send us a text Fresh off the big game the Fat Boys battle it out to see who’s team reigns supreme! Listen to this episode of the Horror for the Holidays […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 73: Kristyby e_xander on November 24, 2025
Send us a text Jeff and Jay take on Kristy for Thanksgiving! Wait Jay, is this just the sacrifice game again but more boring? Welp that’s a spirit breaker. […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 42: Exploring Creepypastas 1by e_xander on November 17, 2025
Jeff and Jay take on Jeff The Killer, I hope the police get to the parking lot at my house in time, this is a nice neighborhood after all! Listen to this […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 72: The Sacrifice Gameby e_xander on November 10, 2025
Jeff and Jay set the table for the sacrifice game! Jay I wish you and I had died watching this movie! But Jeff, couldn’t you just wish we hadn’t seen it? […]
- 2025 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular Episode 5: Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myersby e_xander on October 27, 2025
As Jeff and Jay reach the end of the 2025 spooktacular they ask the hard hitting questions! Why is Michael back? Can he leave again? Did he stop his steroids? […]
- 2025 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular Episode 4: Terrifier 2by e_xander on October 20, 2025
Jay and Jeff dive into the Terrifier universe for a second time! Movie boooorrrrrring, boring Jay, movie toooooo long. First movie tooooo short, toooo little […]
- 2025 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular Episode 3: Pumpkinhead Ashes To Ashesby e_xander on October 13, 2025
Jeff and Jay are heading pack for a third slice of the Pumpkinhead! Bunt you must go to the Dagobah system! Listen to this episode of the Horror for the […]