About this podcast
Jay and Jeff take on the best and worst the holiday horror world has to offer. Watch as two semi-qualified critics slog through endless shlock to finally answer the question, what is the pie for? WARNING: Strong language is used so don’t listen around little ones.
Visit Horror for the Holidays page
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 47: Send Help
by e_xander on February 16, 2026Send a text Jay and Jeff discuss the latest Sam Raimi movie and other movie related things. You know the drill, oh no not the drill! Listen to this episode of […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 78:Valentineby e_xander on February 9, 2026
Send us a text Jay and Jeff watch a series of progressively more unlikable characters misidentify perverts and fat people. Then much to our great relief they […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 46: Primateby e_xander on February 2, 2026
Send us a text Jeff and Jay talk Primate and whether a chimp could lift Jeff! Spoiler alert probably not, ha take that Ben! Listen to this episode of the […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 77: Gnome Sick: 7 Slays Til Mithrasby e_xander on January 26, 2026
Send us a text Jeff and Jay discuss whether bad cgi gnomes and a pagan cult are too cerebral for the modern audience! Jay buys more Oreos! Listen to this […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 45: Second Annual Christmas Party!by e_xander on January 19, 2026
Send us a text The OG fat boys talk about their Christmas goings on and toss another eggnog on the fire. Listen to this episode of the Horror for the Holidays […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 76: The Apologyby e_xander on January 12, 2026
Send us a text The boys finally apologize for all the bad things they’ve done. Ironic that this episode is the debut of Unapologetic Jeff. Listen to this […]
- Technical Difficulties! The Show Will Return January 12th!by e_xander on December 29, 2025
Send us a text Jay lost power and Jeff lost his will to live! Listen to this episode of the Horror for the Holidays podcast Author: Horror For The Holidays […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 75: Krampusby e_xander on December 22, 2025
Send us a text Jeff and Jay find out what happens when you lose the Christmas spirit and get attacked by killer Gingerbread men! Krampus is there too! Kind of! […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 44: Exploring Creepypasta Vol. 2!by e_xander on December 15, 2025
Send us a text Jeff and Jay join Squidward on the sewer slide! Listen to this episode of the Horror for the Holidays podcast Author: Horror For The Holidays […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 74: ATMby e_xander on December 8, 2025
Send us a text Jeff and Jay battle their way through the field of plot holes and wasted opportunities to withdraw some cash! Was it worth it? You decide! Also […]