Murdered by Mummers: The Christmas Killing that Outlawed Costumes
A knock at the door at Christmas. Strangers in homemade disguises. And you let them in. Welcome to Newfoundland mummering.
“Any mummers ‘lowed in?” For generations, Newfoundlanders have opened their kitchen doors to masked visitors who talk on the in-breath to hide their voices, while everyone tries to guess who’s under the disguise. Guess right, and the mask comes off and the food comes out.
But in the 1860s, this cozy custom landed on the wrong side of the law. After a deadly Christmas attack on a road in Bay Roberts, Newfoundland made you get a permit to wear a mask, then banned disguises outright. Jeff Loftin tells the true story, busts a few myths, and follows how the kitchen visit quietly outlasted the ban and came back with a parade.
Stay after the sign-off for more of the extended tales from the world of The Lost Years of Santa Claus.
Next week: The Santa Claus Man. Who was really reading your letters to Santa?
Notes and sources:
Scholarly
- Joy Fraser, “Mummers on Trial: Mumming, Violence and the Law in Conception Bay and St. John’s, Newfoundland, 1831–1863,” Shima 3(2), 2009: https://www.shimajournal.org/issues/v3n2/h.-Fraser-Shima-v3n2-70-88.pdf
- Diane Tye, “At Home and Away,” Material Culture Review 68 (2008): https://journals.lib.unb.ca/index.php/MCR/article/download/18133/19498?inline=1
- Halpert & Story (eds.), Christmas Mumming in Newfoundland (1969): https://archive.org/details/christmasmumming0000unse_d6y5
- DCHP-3, “mummering”: https://dchp.arts.ubc.ca/entries/mummering
Heritage and archives
- Kristin Harris Walsh, “Mummering,” Heritage NL: https://heritagenl.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/6-Mummering.pdf
- Heritage NL, “Election Riots of 1861”: https://www.heritage.nf.ca/law/riots_1861.html
- Community Stories, “The Isaac Mercer Mummer Murder Gate”: https://www.communitystories.ca/v2/heritage-places-bay-roberts_lieux-patrimoine/story/the-isaac-mercer-mummer-murder-gate/
- MUN Intangible Cultural Heritage Inventory, “Mummering”: https://www.mun.ca/ich/inventory/profiles/xmastrad/mummering.php
- Mummers Festival, Traditions: https://mummersfestival.ca/traditions
News and magazines
- CBC, Terri Coles (2018): https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/dark-mummering-crime-murder-1.4940745
- The Globe and Mail, “The dark history of mummering in Newfoundland”: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-the-dark-history-of-mummering-in-newfoundland/
- Product of Newfoundland, “Newfoundland mummer murder”: https://www.productofnewfoundland.ca/articles/newfoundland-mummer-murder
- Hakai Magazine, “Return of the Mummers” (2016): https://hakaimagazine.com/features/return-mummers/
- Atlas Obscura: https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/the-longbanned-tradition-of-mummering-in-newfoundland-is-making-a-comeback
- VOCM (2019): https://vocm.com/2019/12/25/beloved-mummering-traditions-once-outlawed/
- Wikipedia, Mummering (for Fraser’s “selective and idealised” remark): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mummering
Contact:
email
website
Special thanks to:
The Christmas Song/Heaven/Slow 3/4 Song by Peter Evans, Tom Blancarte, and Brandon Seabrook – CC by 3.0
Santa Claws is Coming by Ergo Phizmiz – CC by 3.0
holiday by Dee Yan-Key – CC by 3.0
Listen to this episode of the Lost Christmas Podcast
Author: The Chronicler
Title: Murdered by Mummers: The Christmas Killing that Outlawed Costumes



