About this podcast
Jay and Jeff take on the best and worst the holiday horror world has to offer. Watch as two semi-qualified critics slog through endless shlock to finally answer the question, what is the pie for? WARNING: Strong language is used so don’t listen around little ones.
Visit Horror for the Holidays page
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 57: Golden Chainsaw Awards 2026
by e_xander on July 27, 2026Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff decide which movies deserve the awards and as the only correct critics on earth this list supersedes the actual results. Listen […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 86: Werewolf Santaby e_xander on July 20, 2026
Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay head back to the jolly old UK to hunt some werewolves! I hope someone in our group isn’t secretly a werewolf……. Listen to […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 56: Fat Boy Summer Movie Round-upby e_xander on July 6, 2026
Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff talk about Obsession, The Backrooms, and the Scary Movie(2026). Listen to this episode of the Horror for the Holidays podcast […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 85: Uncle Samby e_xander on June 29, 2026
Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay get a crash course in patriotism from their uncle……Sam! Watch as possibly the worst child actor attempts to carry a movie […]
- Fat Boy Summer Episode 6: Joy Ride 3 Roadkill Unratedby e_xander on June 15, 2026
Send us Fan Mail The Fat Boys reach the end of line for this summer and in a pleasant surprise the director actually remembered to make a Joy Ride Movie this […]
- Fat Boy Summer Episode 5: Joy Ride 2 Dead Ahead Unratedby e_xander on June 8, 2026
Send us Fan Mail Hey Jay, turns out if your movie is direct to video you can call it unrated, too bad it still sucks. The fat boys are at it again folks and […]
- Fat Boy Summer Episode 4: Joy Rideby e_xander on June 1, 2026
Send us Fan Mail The Fat Boys are back and on the road this time. Hey audience, I…..uhhh……I take off your bra. Listen to this episode of the Horror for […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 55: Hokum and other nonsense!by e_xander on May 25, 2026
Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff talk Hokum and more on this exciting edition of…….Stocking Stuffers! Listen to this episode of the Horror for the Holidays […]
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 84: The Beast Of Walton St.by e_xander on May 18, 2026
Send us Fan Mail You thought there were two beasts, Brock Lesnar and Jeff Searcy! But what if I told you there was a third beast? Jeff and Jay head to the […]
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 54: Over Your Dead Bodyby e_xander on May 11, 2026
Send us Fan Mail Jay is dying of consumption but Jeff still forced him to make content for you! Join us for the summer of soda and a regular episode next week! […]